First off, I would like to say that these should be rated as CTF, as they were uploaded, and the tileset is not the centerpiece of this upload.
Secondly, I would like to say that I obviously am rating this lower because I am rating the CTF levels. Not only that, but it has became apparent to me that I obviously like even the levels less than anyone here, but anyway, I will go on, and try to gather some basis for my rating, since it probably seems a bit strict.
Here are two levels by Jeh, and a tileset. Since I will be rating the levels as the upload type specifies, my grade probably will seem a tad low. And it is. Because I am not a fan of these levels in any respect. The flow on it is far below average, the eyecandy is fantastic, but that does not make up for all of the other sins that this level makes, and the weapon placement is just mediocre. The more intersting part of this download is the included tileset, 7th Lava Fall, which absolutely and totally pwns. Unfortunately, I can not rate the tileset as much as the level since this was designated as Capture the Flag, so I will have to give this a 6.2. I know the rating seems very low compared to the others, but I can not say that I am fond of this level at all. The tileset is absolute 0wnage, but the level is simply pretty with little on the inside. I can see why people like the tileset so much and therefore rate as if they were rating the tileset…but…well…this was uploaded under Capture the Flag, and therefore it deserves to be rated as so.
The levels included are both of fairly medicore quality. Eyecandy is OK, but gameplay is just awful. I find no reason to recommend this download other than for those who really wish to get the tileset. I know this rating may seem terribly unfair, and it may be, but this IS the levels that should be rated, as the uploading class states. Download recommendation for those who do not have the tileset, but avoid for those who do. The levels are simply extra fluff that will simply add to download time.
Nice job on the tileset, but the levels are…bleh. In conclusion, this is a great tileset. But it should have been uploaded under tileset. Then I could say this is a 9.0 tileset with some OK example levels that are good enough for a quick play. Instead, my rating is 6.2. As always, upload classification can make all the difference.[This review has been edited by Trafton AT]