Jazz 1: Stonar

  • Rating: 6.9

Reviews and comments

    MoonBlazE Posted more than 20 years ago

    6

    As you may see, this aren’t a perfect conversion.
    Like on the mountains, the black isen’t the same, which looks very odd.
    CelL didn’t add extra stuff from jj2 like poles, sucker tubes, descrout blocks ect.
    Also, a good conversion has an usual texture background, here the normal red background dosen’t even work in texture.
    This was a bit disappointing.
    You should download it if its needed.

    Did you think this was a good review? Yes/No

    Blackraptor Posted more than 20 years ago

    6

    Yeah, nothing that specal, but overall its good, download it if you dont have it.

    This is a short review. It has less impact on the upload's score.

    Violet CLM Posted more than 20 years ago

    8

    Heh… I would have loved this (and doubtless other people too) if not for mine, which make me want to scream at you “Where are the sucker tubes? The poles? Why doesn’t the textured background even WORK?!”
    Anyway, this is an update of CelL’s other Stonar conversions, with better colors. Except for the background mountains. The mountains are more then one shade of black, so they look all wrong. Btw, CelL, in the future, here’s something useful to know. JJ1 tilesets DO have both night and day versions, so be careful.
    Still, this is a fun and useful tileset. Fix the background and the mountains and it would get a better rating, though.

    Edit: Ok, CelL reuploaded it and now the mountains are fixed, it has a vine, H/V poles, blocks and sucker tubes. The sucker tubes aren’t made for T formations, but oh well.
    Also, if the H/V poles were also available on at least one of the layer 4 backgrounds, that would be helpful.. but oh well. And the textured background still doesn’t work.
    Nice fixing otherwise, though.[This review has been edited by Violet CLM]

    Did you think this was a good review? Yes/No

    Krezack Posted more than 20 years ago

    8

    Nice. Better than the official one, IMHO.

    This is a short review. It has less impact on the upload's score.

    American Posted more than 20 years ago

    I’ve always thought that the old Stonar conversion needed an update, so I’m glad to see CelL has decided to take on the task. While the original tileset conversion was fairly true to Jazz 1: Stonar, the colors were a bit washed out and some tiles didn’t look right. It seems these problems have been fixed almost completely in the new version. And Kudos to CelL on the pallete. All in all, this is a good update to an already good conversion. I’m not going to rate it because it’s basically just an update of the original, but it’s still definitely worth a downloader…err download.[This review has been edited by Trafton AT]

    Did you think this was a good review? Yes/No