I agree with Moonblaze, I don’t think this is a 9.7
We’ll see, here’s my review.
TILESET
When I was looking on the set the first time in the example level I thought ‘Wow! This tileset looks great!’
But when I tried to make a level with it I fastly noticed that there just wheren’t the tiles I needed.
Spazie sais: ‘You included all the needed tiles, hooks blabla…’
All needed tiles?
There’s a txt sign but only for one background, I would’ve needed a text sign for the stones. Also I miss some platforms with thin masking, but not too thin for a puzzle. I tried the cactus tiles, but they don’t work for it.
Also, what Moonblaze said, the background looks weird, the sand is lighter than the sprite layer ground, the clouds don’t look like clouds.
What I like is the foreground. The sandstorm and the rain looks cool. But what is good foreground without good background? Nope!
The houses for layer 4 are ok, though they remind me a bit on one of Blades tilesets. However, the whole tileset reminds me on one of Blades tilesets :P
Well, to say something good (don’t wanna see Violet crying :P) the ground looks good (tough, darker than the bg sand) and I like the quicksand.
SCORE: 6.5 out of 10
LEVEL
The example level isn’t bad, tough I don’t understand why there’s all those regenerating ice ammo. The level doesn’t have enemies, but shows well how to use the tileset. I really like how Violet did the Quicksand, and I didn’t knew that you can use sucker tube speed 0 (I thought 1 is the lowest).
SCORE: 4.0 out of 5
MUSIC
I really like the music Violet found, it fits perfectly.
SCORE: 5.0 out of 5
CONCLUSION
So, I hope these are enough reasons why this tileset doesn’t deserve 9.7 (Beware!). Don’t get mad please, I know you can do it, Violet. You have the ability to make very good sets (and not many people have that ability). Your next tileset will be better I think :D
FINAL SCORE: 6.7
See ya, PHT
EDIT: lol, Spazie started with rating it 9.7, now it’s 8.2 lol!
@ Cooba: Even if it’s ripped from JJ1, does it matter? No! (in my opinion)
@ Violet: It is a race level? OH! sorry :D I didn’t knew that :P
Rating raised to 7 because I’m dumb :P
Oh, and another note to Violet, please don’t mind Bjarni, it isn’t his fault (read JSZ Jazz’ article about autism)[This review has been edited by PHT]