Carrastle

  • Rating: 7.1

Reviews and comments

    MoonBlazE 16 Apr 2009, 11:03

    3Not recommended:

    When reviewing a tileset such as this you need to remember to review only the effort in joining the tilesets and not the art that is drawn by someone else.

    Joining two tilesets is more about recoloring and editing existing tiles. Running out of colors isn’t an excuse for a job not done, as you have over two hundred colors available and the possibility to edit current tiles to fit the new color schemes is there.

    This seems more like the author ran the sets through a color reduction program and splattered them into whatever available space a pre-made palette.

    Although the idea of Carrotus joined with Castle in one tileset is interesting, the choices of tiles still need to be well thought and the colors well handled.

    I apologize, but download is not recommended.

    2 of 3 people found this a good review. Did you? Yes/No

    Gaunt 16 Sep 2007, 13:45

    9Recommended:

    Tileset like this was made in the past (the tileset “Froggy”), but his tileset is better and very usefull.
    The main bug in this tileset is the sky of the carrotus tileset, but it is not so bad.
    I like the idea of combine two different tileset, and I hope you will make another tilesets like this in the future.

    This is a short review. It has less impact on the upload's score.

    Typhoon Bunny 26 Sep 2007, 11:29 (edited 26 Sep 07, 12:44 by Cooba)

    6Recommended:

    I think, it’s a good tileset but you created it very easy! There aren’t special blocks or objects in the tileset, only carrots on some castle blocks.My rating is 6.2.Dowload recommendation!

    [Review changed to quick review. For more information, see \Review Rules\. – Cooba]

    Did you think this was a good review? Yes/No

    Narsist 29 Jan 2010, 16:01

    10Recommended:

    Good idea and good tileset!

    This is a short review. It has less impact on the upload's score.

    djazz 8 Apr 2009, 22:18 (edited 8 Apr 09, 22:39)

    9Recommended:

    WOW! Thsi is a really great JJ2 tileset conversion! Sry for the carrots, but’s still cool =D

    Rate: 9 of 10 due to the pinball events & carrots, and try to change the color of the pinball events instead of neon-green
    Download: Absolutley ;)

    To fix the 500 bump and carrot bump, put those colors in tileset, took a long time and many tries before I figured this out =)

    0 of 2 people found this a good review. Did you? Yes/No

    sonicnathan 1 6 Apr 2009, 18:36 (edited 14 Apr 09, 22:36)

    Well not bad, but not perfect.

    What this is: This is basically the castle and carrotus tileset put in a blender and compiled. While I do agree that this is a good idea, some things could have been changed.

    Color
    For the most part, the color looks good. Castle looks the same and carrotus looks the same. The only problem is with the carrots, they look bad. The textured background looks good and looks corrected. Overall, good colors.
    8/10

    Pallet Events
    This is a big hitter. Almost non of them work. even the carrotus pole doesn’t work. The only thing that works well is the Textured background and water. Just the fact the carrotus pole doesn’t work really hurts this.
    2/10

    Ease of Use
    Well this is a quite a bit harder to use then the other tilesets. You kinda need to know them both to use them effectively. Even so, it’s still easy to use.
    7/10

    Usability
    This tileset is very usable. You can make quite a couple of combinations. That being said, it’s still only castle and carrotus, meaning you’re limited to those two themes. Even so, there’s still quite a bit of re-usability here.
    7/10

    Added stuff
    Almost nothing. All that really has been added are the connection tiles. There could have a lot more that could have been added.
    2/10

    Mask
    Almost non of the masking bugs have been fixed. that being said, the masking still works most of the time. I would have liked the masking fixed.
    6/10

    Final Score:31/60
    Score:5.5
    Rank C
    DR? Well this is a hard one. This is a good tileset, but I think a lot more could have been done (Mask fix, more tiles)other then just pasting the two tilesets together. Still, if you want something like this, go ahead and download as it does work, just don’t expect anything spectacular.

    Edit:I remove my rating since there was another update.

    1 person found this a good review. Did you? Yes/No

    Bluespaz7 7 Apr 2009, 10:52 (edited 7 Apr 09, 10:53)

    Doesn’t one of these exsist already?

    tonius11 9 Apr 2009, 07:07 (edited 9 Apr 09, 07:10)

    I tried that djazz, but is STAYS ugly!
    >:(

    AND the neon colors of pinball events is because of the necessary colors of the carrotus pole.

    Spaz.Spaz.tg 25 Jun 2009, 12:29

    i could be better for me if it was 1.23 x_x