Review by Genotoxin aka iCeD

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Dark Forest Fight
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
6.5

Wow.. ANOTHER level using the (evil) Diamondus tileset. Well regardless, this level is pretty decent. You did a nice job perfecting the eye candy (the bg needs to move vertically a little faster though), but the layout if kinda awkward which I didn’t like too much. You need to work on making the layout a little more fluent and playable before you release a level. Also, the weapon placement was… strange, to say the least. (placing a mass of weapons near hills and such is usually a bad idea). Another fluency problem… the dead ends can steal away from a battle at times. Watch your use of them.

Overall: Sure, d/l this. You get some extra points for the eye candy.

Review by $n!pêr

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: An Impossible Mission II
Level rating: 6.8
Rating
8

Sorry, I’‘ve forget to give this lvl a rating, but here is he…….

Review by JelZe

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Dark Forest Fight
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
N/A

You oughta know Nitro did most of the work. I only only did a smal part of the level, the eye candy and the bg…

Review by Derby

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Dark Forest Fight
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
7

Introduction to Dark Forest Fight:

Dark Forest Fight is a small battle level made in the Diamondus Night tileset.

Content:

One level file and one text file.

Unbiased Review:

The unbiased review points out a little differently from what I think of this level.

Design/Content: 2.0/2.5

The overall level design, if you look at it from far away, seems pretty nice. The actual level is hindered by other problems, which I’ll mention in another part of the review. Certain parts of the level design made the battle focus only in a few areas of the level. This problem is actually with both the level design and the event placement. The level’s size might have made it more difficult to place events well.

Tile/Tile compatibility: 2.5/2.5

Perhaps the strongest part of the creation was the compatibility with the tiles. No tiles were overused, and as you can see, there is variety in how the tiles were used. This made up a strong part of the eyecandy in this level.

Tile/Event Compatibility: 1.0/2.0

If you look at how the tiles and events were used together, you’ll notice that they weren’t used together at all. This battle level is dead, when you consider the variety of uses with tiles and events. One ways were used in the level wisely, and some destructible scenery.

Event/event compatibility: 0.5/1.0

Event placement is more difficult with smaller levels. Weapon placement in this battle level was poor. Carrots are near each other in this small battle level, though the long regeneration time makes up for it.

Layer use: 1.0/2.0**

The reappearing trunks in the foreground can get somewhat annoying when they’re as close as they are in this level. The background in an area can be very confusing, making you think that you’re jumping on a platform. In a certain portion of the level, vines are covered by land in the foreground, plunging you into confusion for the first time in play. In some cases, the use of the layers added to the eyecandy. The excessive leaves flying in the foreground are also a little annoying after a while.

Game compatibility: -0.0/-1.0**

You probably won’t find any problems finding or playing this level. The level is named well, and like most JJ2 creations, it functions.

Overall rating: 7.0/10.0

A rating of 7.0 out of 10.0 signifies that this level is considered halfway between “OK” and “Good.”

Biased Review:

The biased review focuses on other issues that tie in with my opinion, and does not count towards the level’s rating.

Replayability: 2.5/5.0

I really don’t believe this level would actually hold out for long with the gameplay it presents. Several things hold it from
being an acknowledgeable level.

My opinion on this level: 3.5/5.0

The best that could have been brought out from this level’s design was removed from the poor weapon placements and event properties. The eyecandy wasn’t up to par with the standard, but it was the strongest point of the level besides the design itself.

My overall rating: 6.0/10.0*

As with previous reviews, my review is a little harsher than the unbiased portion. The average margin so far is 1.0, which this evens out to.

True rating: 6.5/10.0*

The combination of the two reviews makes this well-cut rating.

Summary:

Basically, when you download this, you’ll get a mediocre battle level that lacks only in the event, life, and layer use departments.

How could this level be improved?

Don’t overuse the foreground layers. If you use the background layers, don’t make them so confusing. This small level
needs less weapons in each place. If you can satisfy those conditions in this level, you’ll satisfy others’ tastes.

Interesting fact:

The only destructible scenery in the level is that of the traditional "shootable signs."

~ Derby

  • Only the unbiased rating counts towards the site’s review rating system.

** An important change in my reviews gives designers a smaller edge by subtracting points for game incompatibilities and an extra point for layer use, being more important.

Review by EWarrior aka MrPlonker

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
N/A

wot do you mean?

Review by aiko

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Dark Forest Fight
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
7

Aha. An isrealic(sp?)-dutch co-production. Well, as you may have noticed, Diamondus isn’t my favourite tileset nowadays. I wonder why people still make Diamondus levels ;-)
However, the design and eyecandy is really good. Esspecially the design: it allows super fluent jumping & running and the weapon selection is very appropriate.
The events (springs, poles, hidden vines etc.) are also very well placed.
To sum it up, "Dark Forest Fight" is a very decent battle level to DOWNLOAD and ADD to your collection. No more, no less.

Review by aiko

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
6.5

Well, "Gamecreators Desert" is a nice, quite small battle map that uses Blade’s awesome and very underused "Desert" tileset. The level layout itself is good and i also noticed some layer work. Nothing too exciting though :-)
And the "Medivo" music doesn’t fit too well in my opinion.
Overall, a good download for all battle and Blade fans i think.
On a side note, the level seems to use an OLDER (i think JelZe is wrong :-) version of Blade’s tileset, which is very annoying because you have to overwrite the newer version to display the level correctly.

P.S.:
I’m not an admin (they don’t want me to be one :-) but i can give warnings as well: if you continue behaving like this, "EWarrior aka MrPlonker", Mr. Quist will know what to do. This is not an idiots playground.

Review by SteelTalon

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Dark Forest Fight
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
5.7

DADADADA… it’s time for ST’s random rate of the week again! This time, it’s early! YaY.

First on the agenda is eyecandy. Good, but could be improved in a few places. There were some annoying tricks and a few monotonous eyecandy pieces.

EYECANDY: 2.5/3

Now, about layouts. If I could sum it up in one word, it’d be "almost". This level feels a bit loose and open in some places. It almost seems like if you pulled a drawstring it’d tighten up and be great. Carrots were in niches, and a few places were one-way streets. Pretty average. Weapons were very overused and in funky formations. No useless TNT, though. Coins were a bit hard to get, and I didn’t like those sucker tubes just in the middle of the ground.

WEAPONS: .8/2
NAVIGATION/CARROTS: 2/4

TOTAL LAYOUT: 2.8/6

The overall feel of this level feels incomplete. The level gives off a sense of being thrown together and basically, "missing a roof". You’d think it was half-done if you were going on gut feeling alone. Good, but it’s missing something…

OVERALL "FEEL": .5/1

Closing Remarks: It’s got it’s "15 minutes of fun", but it isn’t really tight and smooth enough to put on your "favorites" list. Nice effort, overall. I still can’t shake that there was that notion to get a polished feel on a half-finished level, though…

TOTAL SCORE: 5.8/10
ROUNDED TOTAL: 5.7

Review by FireClaw

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Dark Forest Fight
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
7.7

A very nice level, really. Fairly interesting layout, eye candy, and event placement. Did find a few flaws. One of the most annoying, was that you pretty much have to know the level a bit to play in it right, you’ll find the eye candy kinda seems like it’s in the… Forground layer. But I don’t think this should stop you from liking it.

Also, am undecided rather it’s worth a 7.5, or an 8, so I guess I’ll rate it 7.7.

Should be well worth your download, anyway.

Review by Blade

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
7.7

I’ve been little quiet. If you’ve even noticed it. The reason is my new release.

This one is good. It’s little small, but it don’t matter so much. Weapon placing Ok, and the layer work was too pretty good. One complaint: Gc used too many same kind tiles next to each other.

And thanks for supporting!

Review by SPLASHcc

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: Keen on Tubelectric
Level rating: 7
Rating
7

at first i think its very …. that u made it hide in hcl list.
second..the level is good, but confusing
the puzzle is very good
the music is not bad either
d/l it now

Review by JelZe

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
7.2

Ok, my turn ;)

GC Desert 2 is a … fairly good level. Lay-out is OK (no dead ends in battles, plz), weapon placement also (could have been a bit more). But what i didn’t like was that GC used the ORIGINAL Desert tileset. I play in 8-bit, so the 3D bg is…you know. Speaking of background, i HATE it when ppl use the other layers to boost the eye candy in layer 4. Music choice: average (Medivo2), you could easily use a custom file for this.

Conclusion: not bad. That’s all i can say.

-JelZe GoldRabbit

Review by EWarrior aka MrPlonker

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
N/A

milger

Review by Nimrod CC

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
8.5

The level has a nice layout and very good eyecandy. It uses Blade Cool Desert Tileset.

I think its worth about a 8.5

Nimrod

Review by FireClaw

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
6.5

Not a bad peice of work. Design isn’t bad, has a fairly creative layout. Eye candy ain’t bad, just the right amount. But I just wish I could say the same about Events placement, not bad, just OK. Also, they are a few bugs, which could be a bit annoying. And annoying dead ends, also.

Anyway, I’m sure it’s worth your download.

Review by Genotoxin aka iCeD

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
7

Not a bad level at all.
The very first complaint I have for this has nothing to do with the level at all, it’s the ZIP. You made it extract to a new dir which I think is VERY annoying. but getting beyond that, the level is good. It has a nice layout and okay event placement, some tile errors were present and eye candy could have been easily improved. Also the weapons were weirdly placed. All of the other events were fine though. Everything else wasn’t so great.

Overall you can sure d/l this. (I was pretty undecided between 6.5 and 7 here..)

Review by EWarrior aka MrPlonker

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
N/A

LOOK PEOPLE STOP ARGUING AND WATCH TONIGHT WITH TREVOR MCDONALD!

Review by FQuist

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
N/A

Good.

Review by gamecreator

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
N/A

i know what was wrong Fquist,
I uploaded a .j2l file !!
and no .zip file!

Sorry,

Review by FQuist

Posted:
Posted more than 20 years ago
For: GC Desert 2
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
N/A

It was not your pc. You should not upload levels with the wrong name..