Review by master sven

Posted:
14 Jun 2012, 10:52 (edited 1 Jul 12, 07:47)
For: Diamondus Woods
Level rating: 6.3
Rating
N/A

wadle is back :O
WB!

@TW: Imo your grade for music is a too big part of your final grade for a level.
All you can judge a levelmaker on is if the music fits the level.

RecommendedQuick Review by Laro B.

Posted:
7 Jun 2012, 19:31 (edited 8 Jun 12, 15:25)
For: Diamondus Woods
Level rating: 6.3
Rating
6.7

These were solid levels to play. While the eyecandy wasn’t so very special, there were some decent enemy placements. I enjoyed this, keep on JCSing!

RecommendedQuick Review by Rabid Rabb

Posted:
21 May 2012, 16:29 (edited 21 May 12, 16:30)
For: Labratory Remix (Impulse Tracker)
Level rating: 9
Rating
9

Really great thing, it’s perceptible how it’s formed in adept hands. It would be great to get concentrated types of music, with quality like this. Here i mean Electronic, DnB or Dubstep, things like these.

RecommendedQuick Review by Ron97

Posted:
15 May 2012, 10:14
For: A flying Star Above Us...
Level rating: 8.1
Rating
8.2

A good level with a fine flow and great eyecandy, considering the tileset limits. Has some nice ideas. I’d definitely give a DL rec.

Review by GLaDOS

Posted:
13 May 2012, 18:46
For: Perfect Battle Arena
Level rating: 9
Rating
N/A

Nice map!
Thank you very much, Lithium! :3

Review by cooba

Posted:
13 May 2012, 18:01 (edited 13 May 12, 18:50)
For: Perfect Battle Arena
Level rating: 9
Rating
N/A

Lithium: Fair enough, I didn’t notice that.

Review by Ron97

Posted:
13 May 2012, 13:07 (edited 13 May 12, 13:24)
For: Perfect Battle Arena
Level rating: 9
Rating
N/A

Cooba: they were BETATESTERS, they had ACCESS to the level. Pretty much the same as with Rag and you.

RecommendedQuick Review by Zoro

Posted:
13 May 2012, 10:43 (edited 13 May 12, 21:40)
For: Perfect Battle Arena
Level rating: 9
Rating
9

Happy birthday Glados!!

And good level, gj Lith!

RecommendedQuick Review by wKtK

Posted:
13 May 2012, 10:19 (edited 13 May 12, 18:46)
For: Perfect Battle Arena
Level rating: 9
Rating
9

Happy birthday!

The level looks great, I’ll add it to my levellist.

RecommendedQuick Review by Zoro

Posted:
3 May 2012, 05:46
For: New Ages V
Level rating: 9.6
Rating
10

Wheeee :D
GJ snz… U PWN as always…

RecommendedQuick Review by PT32

Posted:
29 Apr 2012, 16:18
For: Pearl-Shell Shore (DOM)
Level rating: 8.8
Rating
8.8

Not much to say here that hasn’t already been said. Good layout, smooth flow, nice eyecandy, excellent eventage.

I wasn’t too impressed with the sand-colored Layer 8 BG, the campable Seeker powerup or the music (which I felt was a rather poor fit), but overall the level was nice and definitely deserves a DL.

RecommendedQuick Review by PT32

Posted:
28 Apr 2012, 12:50 (edited 28 Apr 12, 12:54)
For: Wicked Wood
Level rating: 8.9
Rating
8.7

I loved this. Good atmosphere (the music was an excellent choice), smooth gameplay, nice gameplay. Only downside was that I felt the bases were too close, but this may be due to the level’s size.

I disagree with Redmsr, because the level seemed more somber than spooky.

DL recommended. I wish somebody’d give this level a good review.

Review by master sven

Posted:
27 Apr 2012, 07:10 (edited 27 Apr 12, 07:11)
For: Foreign Face
Level rating: 7
Rating
7

Long time ago I wrote a review, lets see.

Gameplay:

The size of the playable area is balanced nicely overall, there are no big area’s without tiles and there are only a few narrow area’s. The warp from the bottom to the middle means that one can constantly fall down and get back up which could turn especially duels a bit less internesting.

Eyecandy:

The edges of the level are very straight, I would have prefered some different lines in the walls, you could have made them symitrical as well. When jumping around a bit at the C+1 you notice a black line in the top of the background.
The rest of the background is nice and the middle part of the layer 4 of the map is quite good and nicely shaped.

Originality:

I think few maps in this shape have been made, its looks nice, you did a good job, though I always apreciate it when people use different methods than springs and warps to create ways up.

Gameplay: 6,5
Eyecandy: 7,5
Originality: 7

Final Grade: 7

RecommendedReview by Rabid Rabb

Posted:
23 Apr 2012, 21:45 (edited 23 Apr 12, 23:25 by Violet CLM)
For: Murky Wood
Level rating: 7
Rating
7.2

So, a small singe player level.

For the first look, i tought it looks cool, it has a good – and somewhat original eyecandy. I love that it’s covered with a black transpalucent layer, it obviously fits with the name and feel. Actually i liked the background, was also a great point. By the way as it has to come, there are bad things. one is that the things moving with you are somewhere a bit empty, there are some tilebugs (that could’ve been noticed if you go trough the level like 1-2 times and look for it). the feeling of it is fine, but in several parts it makes the way uncertain. After some deaths it wasn’t that but it’s still confusing.

eyecandy: 21/30

Enemies, flow, pickups and other droughty things: I started it and i fell down close immediately, i tought i will die, then i tought i will have to climb back. uh… i didnt get how it was meant to fall until i played like the 3/4 of the level. The first thing came in my mind was the tree that was used as masked, unmasek bg and unmasked fg too. It was deceptive. Anyway, after realising what’s going on, playing became fun, There were some unnoticable cactuses, some suprising enemies, it was the thing that hurted, because most enemies weren’t too hard to kill. the whole thing wasn’t really channeling. There were a great amount of toasters what i loved. Gun6 is the weapon of SP levels. There were a deal of food, once i got a sugar rush (What ended up a werid way, i ran into the Tuf Boss immedietly killing it. it was rather funny. Also it is shootable and killable, next time dont put unactivated bosses in the way. it even hurts if you touch it.). Mainly the way became clear after a time. it was okay. the ending was hardly understandable, i mean i always got warped to the tuf boss, i could roam to other bosses though. Maybe the channeling thing was not to fall off the trees, It happened a lot with me. The bosses werent that hard (for me). it was rather short, for the time i understood the system of the level it ended. There were unneeded savepoints, one could be enough in the whole map. the others should only be in easy (and some extra carrots too). The hard mode was right, with the more enemies. Dont take these as blaming, i’m just focusing on the things to mention and focus on.

gameplay: 28/40

Aboat the externalities, the music fitted well, the name is appropriate.I like the Jungle gods thing. What more to say aboat it duh.

externalities:10/10

I think it was somewhat original, low used tileset, with this dark cover, new typed bossfight. I could even call it “find it out” as it has lots of strange happenings.

originality: 13/20

Overally: Not bad, but there is where to improve.
Rating: 72/100 -> 7.2 and a DR.

~RabRab

(added a missing closing tag for the bold. ~Violet)

RecommendedQuick Review by Rabid Rabb

Posted:
12 Apr 2012, 19:23
For: Underrated Paradise
Level rating: 8.5
Rating
8.5

Nice work! It acts better than i excepted!

RecommendedReview by Mac.Lynx

Posted:
8 Apr 2012, 08:01 (edited 8 Apr 12, 08:44)
For: Black Jack
Level rating: 8.8
Rating
9.7

Had the honour to play this level yesterday. Checked it out again today and want to give you my impressions.

Gameplay and flow
I am not a fan of too hilly and bumpy CTF levels. Neither do I like too plain and simple layouts. Considering this, Black Jack offers the perfect compromise between both extremes and is the way to go. The following spots are worth being highlighted:

— The pit over the two bases: this comes in extremely handy if you have two hearts and are lingering around your home base, being ready to score. If you have RF ammo and a little bit of skill, your chances are high to get 3 hearts again. Perfect middleway: not easy, but possible.

— The pillars near the two bases: behind them, you are semi-shielded. Electro blaster is placed just right there – great! One way-events are being used and seekers can be shot through the pillars – even better!

— The carrot area (obviously): I really like the concept of the carrot in the wall. Regarding that one can shoot through it, but at the same time might be attacked hard from behind with RF, this carrot is just not campable. Excellent! The only drawback is the slightly too thick mask of the wall, making it unable to immediately get the full carrot from time to time. However, as I guess that there is no better tile in the tileset for this, it’s ok.

— The little caves at the bottom with a warp in them: two aspects have to be covered when it comes to those caves being found to the left and right of the bullet bouncer PU. On the one hand, it’s the level’s size that makes them crucial: this level is BIG. And I really mean BIG. It could possibly serve as a 4v4 level if such thing existed. If you need to get up again quickly, the warps in the caves are your way to go. Same goes for the warps near the carrot area by the way, which bring you to the area described in the next list node. On the other, they are conveniently placed near some of the MP starting points, and they have a seeker crate in them. This level lives of an excessive ammo spamming, and without anything, you are lost (unlike in some other CTF levels). Once you die, you will be grateful for these seekers.

— The area above the carrot: this is where you will be warped to when exiting the carrot area via the springs. An RF powerup is placed there – just like for the electro blaster near the bases, the perfect place. I found myself exiting through this warp many times yesterday – being roasted by CJ with RF just a millisecond later (from the tiny platforms of course). You can also spread RF to the upper corners of the map, killing a fool trying to get the carrot (see list point one for such folks).

— The semi-isolated areas near the bases: vis-à-vis of the top of the bases, you will find apparently sealed areas with broken “tubes” (not the ones you will be sucked through). A good point is that they are not sealed at all – “real” tubes can bring you to the upper hall again if you need to fly away quickly. However, I don’t see too much importance for them for the gameplay. You cannot really attack the base itself, but you can easily be shot with electro blaster from the opponent. I guess Superjazz designed the bases so that you HAVE to jump around them and not stay there and be ready to score. In this case, you eventually may would really be hit from that area. Yet still this is not as effective as attacking from below, shooting seekers up, or even shooting RF missiles from the middle area to the bases.

— The bullet bouncer powerup area: located at the very bottom middle of the level, this area has one purpose: it brings air into the level. Even the most hardcore levels for tricks and stuff like Happy Semiconductor need an area where you will simply be able to move. If this was not the case, you would repeatedly feel smashed in narrow corridors with low-hanging ceilings. As mentioned in list point #4, this area sometimes is a starting point if you die. I myself am glad if I am not lost nowhere in a level when being roasted. This place gives you both space and a good orientation, because you know where you are. Needless to say that again, the powerup placement is done very well (bullets at an area where you can instantly use them). Well done.

— The “caves” below the CTF bases (you can access them from the bottom of the level near the Toaster PUs): there is not much I can say about them other than that they can be handy to reach the base a bit quicker than using the far left (or far right) spring area. However, I got stuck there yesterday at the lower edge. Having checked out the masks and One Way-placements, I can say that this might have been a bug in JJ2 though, because they are fine. Maybe one more row of “One Way”-events would have been needed? I am not sure.

Ammo and powerup placement
Some parts have already been mentioned before. There are four powerups: one RF in the top middle, one Bullet Bouncer in the bottom middle, and two Toaster powerups in the bottom left/right areas. Also mentioned is that they are placed where they need to be (except for the Toaster PU which actually can be put everywhere distant from other PUs). There’s a whole plentiness of ammunition (also seekers which for good reasons have no powerup). The bigger a level is, the more ammo is needed. Also, this way of level design offers a somewhat new gameplay experience. You do not only have to focus on tricks and how to reach area xy (I am a bit biased to this), but you also just have room to fight or even bullfight. I think most of today’s CTF levels lack this feature, and I assume that there are some people around being unable to show off their whole potential due to this fact. This level countersteers this trend. Conclusion: great.

Eyecandy and music
This is where it becomes very subjective, hence the shorter section.
Overall, the eyecandy has been done well too. The metal pillars with a “snake-like” curling of pipes around them is a must if you use this tileset. You can find them at the bases and bottom middle area. If you check out the level from a distance, they sort of border the entire level. I like that. However, keeping in mind that this level is almost entirely symmetrical, I also would have mirrored these pipes below the bullet bouncer area.
Next thing, the chains: I just finished my first CTF level which featured a similar concept: if platforms are tiny, they are “held in place” by chains (like near the RF PU area). It polished the overall view very well. I may would have put even more of them into the level, e.g. below the carrot area – but as I said, this is a subject of taste.
A thing I actually rather disliked were the fences (e.g. in the pits above the CTF bases, or even worse, below them at the Toaster PU). They sort of disturb the eye in my opinion. Luckily enough Superjazz used them sparingly.

All in all, what’s important is that the eyecandy is not very disturbing.

The music choice leaves me with mixed feelings. On the one hand, it represents the cliché-like imagination one has of medieval castles (I mean, isn’t that tileset related to Medivo?): hollow, vast, high ceilings, and tons of echos if you are in them. The music represents this a bit, yes. However, overall there is not much going on in that soundtrack, while the gameplay can be very fast and exhaustive. Sort of a contradiction. However, who cares? And I know how hard it can be to pick the right song. Just wanted to jot this down as a side-note.

Conclusion
I eventually see myself absolutely overwhelmed by this level, which you can also tell by the review. No, I am not biased towards Superjazz or anything (in fact, this is the first long review I have ever done). The only thing that might have influenced my uber-positive impression is that the current mappool for the ladders is horrible. I wish this level got uploaded earlier, and I bet it would have got acceptance by all clans. Besides ladder affairs, this levels has a lot of potential to become a classic.

Download recommended? Guess it.

Rating: 9.7 out of 10. Yes, I am serious. I have thought a long time about it, and for some reason there is the ability to give such a high rating. This level deserves it. Definitely.

Download and enjoy!
Lynx

(edited for a slightly better reading)

RecommendedReview by Laro B.

Posted:
6 Apr 2012, 13:32 (edited 6 Apr 12, 13:35)
For: Black Jack
Level rating: 8.8
Rating
8.7

Finally Vivando made a new CTF level after a long time, and a good one. After hosting this, playing for like an hour, I wanted to give this a full review instead.

Eyecandy:
The EC here is amazing in every detail and I see SJ put quite some effort in making this. Not too much, not too less, just perfect. The music choice was well chosen, it fits the level just right.

Gameplay:
Black Jack has some interesting gameplay to offer, it suits perfect for public games like in Zeal Alpha, or events. The ammo placements are good, interesting C placement, good balanced bases, also suitable for all rabbits, hell, some even want this level in the CTF Ladder mappool!

Download recommended?
Hell yes, this is a good CTF level build by a good JCSer. Too bad you came too late with uploading this, otherwise, it might have gotten in the mappool. Who knows… =P DL now!

Take care,
Laro B.

RecommendedQuick Review by Ron97

Posted:
6 Apr 2012, 12:57
For: Black Jack
Level rating: 8.8
Rating
8.6

A great map with a nice flow, good-looking eyecandy and a fitting music track. I enjoyed playing on it! 8.6 and a dl rec.

RecommendedQuick Review by Superjazz

Posted:
6 Apr 2012, 11:44
For: Resurrection of Evil Episode 2: Spear of Darkness
Level rating: 8.2
Rating
8.4

Overall a decent episode. The storyline was nicely unconventional and interesting, sequel from the previous episode of course. The episode ended in a bit weird way for me, but it’s alright I guess. Graphical side is top-notch in this one, very professionally done. Hard mode was still too easy for me though. Looking forward for the 3rd part. GJ!

Review by Ðx

Posted:
6 Apr 2012, 07:32 (edited 8 Apr 12, 09:36 by cooba)
For: New Ages V
Level rating: 9.6
Rating
N/A

Bad.

  1. 1
  2. 81
  3. 82
  4. 83
  5. 84
  6. 85
  7. 86
  8. 87
  9. 88
  10. 89
  11. 1289